Allied Indus. Scrap, Inc. v. OmniSource Corp.

Plaintiff offered to sell 3 million pounds of scrap copper to the defendant. The defendant negotiated the core terms of the sale but did not object to a fee-shifting provision: “In the event purchaser shall default in his obligations hereunder, purchaser shall be liable for [the plaintiff]’s costs of collection, including attorney’s fees.” The contract was negotiated between two experienced and sophisticated commercial entities. There was no duress. In a suit between the two, the otherwise victorious plaintiff appealed the district court’s ruling that the unilateral fee-shifting clause for attorney’s fees was unenforceable under Ohio law as a matter of public policy. The district court relied on Sixth Circuit precedent, holding that the Ohio Supreme Court would not enforce similar fee-shifting clauses. The Sixth Circuit reversed, noting that the Ohio Supreme Court has since clarified that it would enforce such unilateral or one-sided fee-shifting contract provisions. View "Allied Indus. Scrap, Inc. v. OmniSource Corp." on Justia Law