Justia U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries

by
Police in Tennessee found a firearm under the driver’s seat of a vehicle during an investigation into aggravated assault involving the defendant. He was indicted by a federal grand jury for possessing a firearm as a convicted felon, with an enhanced penalty under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA) based on three prior convictions: robbery (2010), aggravated robbery (2012), and aggravated assault (2022). The defendant pleaded guilty but reserved the right to challenge whether his 2010 robbery conviction qualified as a violent felony under the ACCA.The United States District Court for the Western District of Tennessee considered a presentence report that classified all three prior convictions as violent felonies under the ACCA, resulting in a recommended sentencing range of 188–235 months. The defendant objected to the inclusion of the 2010 robbery conviction, citing the Tennessee Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Curry, arguing that Tennessee robbery no longer categorically required the use or threatened use of physical force. The district court rejected this argument, adopted the presentence report, and sentenced the defendant to 194 months in prison. He appealed this ruling.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court’s determination de novo. The appellate court held that the Tennessee Supreme Court’s decision in Curry did not reinterpret the statutory definition of robbery or its “fear” element as previously articulated in State v. Taylor. The court reaffirmed its prior holding in United States v. Mitchell that Tennessee robbery remains categorically a violent felony under the ACCA, as it requires the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force. Consequently, the appellate court affirmed the district court’s judgment. View "United States v. Bobo" on Justia Law

Posted in: Criminal Law
by
The case centers on Denny Obermiller, who pleaded guilty in Ohio state court to multiple counts of murder and rape involving his grandparents. Following his guilty plea, a three-judge panel conducted a thorough evidentiary hearing, found him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and sentenced him to death after Obermiller waived his right to present mitigating evidence at sentencing. Obermiller later sought to challenge his conviction and mitigation waiver, arguing that his mental illness, specifically bipolar disorder, prevented his plea and waiver from being knowing, voluntary, and intelligent.After sentencing, Obermiller appealed his conviction and sentence. The Ohio Supreme Court reviewed his direct appeal, but Obermiller did not raise issues related to his guilty plea or his mitigation waiver at that stage. Subsequently, he pursued post-conviction relief in state court, attaching new evidence regarding his mental health. The Ohio Court of Appeals, the highest state court to rule on his post-conviction petition, held that Ohio’s res judicata law barred Obermiller from raising these claims because he failed to present them in his direct appeal, even though they could have been raised with the information available at the time.Obermiller then filed a federal habeas petition in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio. The district court found his claims procedurally defaulted and rejected them on the merits. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the denial de novo. The Sixth Circuit held that Obermiller’s claims were barred by Ohio’s res judicata rule as an independent and adequate state ground. Obermiller failed to show cause or prejudice to overcome the procedural default. The court affirmed the district court’s denial of habeas relief, holding that federal review was precluded due to procedural default. View "Obermiller v. Shoop" on Justia Law

by
Ford Global Technologies, LLC and Ford Motor Company worked with InterMotive, Inc. and its founder Gregory E. Schafer to develop an Upfitter Interface Module (UIM) for Ford vehicles. The collaboration was governed by a confidentiality agreement. InterMotive developed and shared with Ford specifications for a programmable UIM, but Ford ultimately ended the project. Some years later, Ford released its own UIM, prompting InterMotive to allege that Ford had misappropriated InterMotive’s trade secret—the use of programmable inputs in such a module.Ford sued InterMotive and Schafer in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, asserting various trademark and unfair competition claims. InterMotive counterclaimed, alleging trademark infringement, trade secret misappropriation under the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act, unfair competition, breach of contract, and false advertising. Most claims survived summary judgment, and Ford’s motion to exclude InterMotive’s implied contract theory from trial was granted. At trial, the jury found for InterMotive on its trade secret, unfair competition, and trademark claims, awarding over $13 million for trade secret misappropriation and a smaller sum for unfair competition. The district court reduced the award to avoid double recovery, denied Ford’s post-trial motions, and declined to enhance damages or allow disgorgement for breach of contract.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the case. It held that the district court correctly denied Ford’s motions for judgment as a matter of law and a new trial, as there was sufficient evidence for the jury to find in InterMotive’s favor on trade secret misappropriation and damages. The court affirmed the district court’s reduction of damages to prevent duplicative recovery, its denial of enhanced damages for trademark infringement, its exclusion of disgorgement for breach of contract, and its exclusion of InterMotive’s implied contract theory for lack of notice. The district court’s rulings were affirmed in full. View "Ford Motor Co. v. InterMotive, Inc." on Justia Law

by
The plaintiffs in this case are individuals convicted of offenses requiring registration under Michigan’s Sex Offender Registration Act (SORA). SORA mandates registrants to report in person to local law enforcement or designated authorities between one and four times annually, depending on their classification tier. Additionally, registrants must report in person after certain life events, such as changes in residence, employment, or education. Failure to comply with these requirements is criminally punishable. The plaintiffs challenged only the in-person-reporting requirements, arguing that these requirements constitute seizures under the Fourth Amendment, due to the threat of criminal liability for noncompliance.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan dismissed the plaintiffs’ complaint. The defendants had argued that the Sixth Circuit’s earlier decision in Willman v. Attorney General of United States was controlling and precluded the plaintiffs’ Fourth Amendment claim. The district court agreed, holding that SORA’s in-person-reporting requirements did not amount to seizures under the Fourth Amendment, and dismissed the case pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6). The plaintiffs timely appealed the dismissal.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court’s dismissal de novo. The court held that SORA’s in-person-reporting requirements do not constitute seizures under the Fourth Amendment, emphasizing that the requirements do not involve abruptness, force, or the type of liberty restraint characteristic of a seizure. The court compared the reporting requirement to court summons and grand jury subpoenas, finding that, while burdensome, the act of reporting does not restrain liberty in the constitutional sense. The court affirmed the district court’s dismissal, holding that the plaintiffs are not seized under the Fourth Amendment due to SORA’s in-person-reporting requirements. View "John Does v. Mich. State Police" on Justia Law

by
Several individuals required to register as sex offenders under Michigan’s Sex Offenders Registration Act (“SORA 2021”) challenged the statute’s constitutionality after its 2021 amendment. Most plaintiffs had committed their offenses before 2011 and had their registration terms retroactively extended, often to lifetime registration, without individualized risk assessments. SORA 2021 retained offense-based tier assignments and many reporting and public notification requirements, although it removed some prior features such as student safety zones and tier designations from public display.The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan certified a class and subclasses, and addressed several constitutional challenges. The district court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs on their ex post facto claims regarding retroactive application, and on procedural due process claims for individuals with non-Michigan convictions, finding that Michigan State Police’s process lacked sufficient procedural protections. It rejected plaintiffs’ substantive due process and equal protection challenges to offense-based tiers and their equal protection challenge to petitioning restrictions, concluding SORA 2021 was rationally related to recidivism reduction. The court also rejected void-for-vagueness claims concerning certain reporting requirements.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court’s judgment de novo. The court vacated and remanded the ex post facto claims and retroactive plea agreement claim for the district court to determine whether they were mooted by a recent Michigan Supreme Court decision holding SORA 2021’s retroactive application unconstitutional. The Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s rejection of substantive due process and equal protection challenges to offense-based tiers and petitioning restrictions, holding these provisions were rationally related to legitimate state interests. It also affirmed the district court’s finding that Michigan’s process for registering individuals with non-Michigan convictions violated procedural due process rights, and upheld the dismissal of void-for-vagueness claims regarding education, employment, and vehicle reporting. The judgment was affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for further proceedings. View "Doe v. Whitmer" on Justia Law

by
Eight plaintiffs challenged Tennessee’s sex-offender-registration law, arguing it retroactively punished them for offenses committed before the registry’s enactment. The law assigns classifications based on offenses and imposes reporting and lifetime registration requirements, as well as geographical restrictions on where registrants may live, work, or be present. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI) maintains the registry, classifies offenders, and publishes relevant information, including certain labels such as “violent sexual offender” and “offender against children.” Plaintiffs alleged these classifications and restrictions violated the Ex Post Facto Clause of the U.S. Constitution.The United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee initially granted summary judgment for plaintiffs, treating the Act as a whole and finding its combined effects punitive. The court issued a broad injunction, ordering plaintiffs’ removal from the registry and enjoining enforcement against them. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit vacated much of this relief, holding plaintiffs lacked standing to sue the Governor, and remanded for provision-specific analysis, instructing the district court to limit relief to provisions enforced by TBI.On remand, the district court found TBI responsible for both the classification and geographical claims, holding that the classifications and several geographical restrictions were punitive and unconstitutional. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the case de novo. It held that while TBI’s classifications operated retroactively, they did not impose punishment under the Ex Post Facto Clause, and thus reversed the classification judgment. For the geographical restrictions, the court found plaintiffs lacked Article III standing against TBI, as their injuries were not fairly traceable to Director Rausch and would not be redressed by relief against him. The court vacated the judgment and permanent injunction regarding the geographical claims and remanded with instructions to dismiss those claims without prejudice. View "John Doe #1 v. Lee" on Justia Law

by
HYC Logistics, a Tennessee-based logistics provider, entered into a contract with OJCommerce (OJC), a Florida-based importer, to transport consumer goods from the Port of Los Angeles to OJC’s California warehouse. While the contract included provisions regarding liens, attorney’s fees, and Tennessee law, payment terms were negotiated separately by email. HYC Logistics billed OJC for various services, but OJC contested the charges, claiming they were inflated, and left a substantial balance unpaid despite making a partial payment. When OJC attempted to cancel a shipment, HYC Logistics exercised its lien rights over nine shipping containers and withheld delivery pending payment.The United States District Court for the Western District of Tennessee presided over the case, which involved both parties asserting multiple claims. A jury found OJC liable for breach of contract and validated HYC Logistics’ exercise of its lien, awarding damages to HYC Logistics. The jury also found HYC Logistics liable for violating the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and for intentional or reckless misrepresentation, awarding damages to OJC on these claims. Post-trial motions resulted in the district court vacating the TCPA verdict against HYC Logistics but upholding the misrepresentation verdict. The court granted HYC Logistics attorney’s fees and denied OJC’s request for fees, and it rejected a motion for Rule 11 sanctions brought by Weiss, OJC’s owner.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the consolidated appeal. It affirmed the district court’s rulings, upholding the jury’s verdicts on breach of contract and lien rights, finding no error in the jury instructions or damages awards, and agreeing with the district court’s grant of attorney’s fees to HYC Logistics. The Sixth Circuit also affirmed the denial of prejudgment interest and Rule 11 sanctions, concluding there was no abuse of discretion or objective unreasonableness in the district court’s decisions. View "HYC Logistics, Inc. v. OJCommerce, LLC" on Justia Law

by
Stefanie Boone, a parent with children enrolled in Lowell Area Schools, publicly criticized the district’s curriculum and practices, particularly those she saw as promoting diversity, equity, inclusion, and social justice issues. She shared her views on a Facebook page, often referencing specific district employees. In response to one post, the high school principal sent Boone a letter requesting that she stop referencing district employees on social media and warning her that failure to comply could result in legal action. The letter also directed her not to contact staff without prior permission. Boone felt threatened and stopped making public comments or contacting teachers directly.Boone filed suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan, naming the district and several officials in their official capacities. She alleged violations of her First and Fourteenth Amendment rights under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, a Title IX violation, and state law claims. The district court granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss, concluding that neither the “Social Media Policy” nor the “Communication Policy” constituted unconstitutional restraints on speech—characterizing the request as non-binding and the communication restriction as merely channeling her speech. The court also rejected her Fourteenth Amendment and Title IX claims and declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over her state law claims.Reviewing the case de novo, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit held that Boone plausibly alleged a First Amendment violation regarding the Social Media Policy, as the district’s letter amounted to a coercive threat of legal action capable of chilling protected speech. However, the Communication Policy, which required Boone to channel communications through administrators, did not violate her speech rights. The court affirmed the dismissal of her Fourteenth Amendment and Title IX claims, reversed the dismissal of her First Amendment claim as to the Social Media Policy, and remanded for further proceedings, including consideration of her state law claims. View "Boone v. Lowell Area Schools" on Justia Law

by
A Michigan state prisoner filed a lawsuit against various defendants, alleging constitutional violations and seeking to proceed in forma pauperis, which would allow him to pay filing fees over time or not at all. The key dispute concerned whether the prisoner had accumulated three “strikes” under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(g), which would bar him from proceeding in forma pauperis unless he was in imminent danger of serious physical injury. Two of the actions identified as strikes by the district court involved claims dismissed on Eleventh Amendment immunity grounds.The United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan denied the prisoner’s request to proceed in forma pauperis, finding that he had three strikes under § 1915(g) and that the imminent-danger exception did not apply. Because he had not paid the filing fee, the court dismissed his action without prejudice. The prisoner appealed, specifically challenging the district court’s determination that two actions dismissed on Eleventh Amendment immunity grounds counted as strikes.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the case de novo. It held that dismissals based solely on Eleventh Amendment immunity grounds do not count as strikes under § 1915(g), unless the dismissing court explicitly labels the claims as frivolous or malicious, which was not done in the actions at issue. The appellate court also determined that issue preclusion did not bar the prisoner from contesting the strike status because the relevant issue was not actually litigated in prior proceedings. Additionally, the court found that the timing of another proposed strike did not meet the statutory requirements. As a result, the Sixth Circuit vacated the district court’s order and remanded for further proceedings, concluding that the prisoner is not barred from proceeding in forma pauperis in this action. View "Henderson v. Kent County" on Justia Law

by
A train carrying hazardous chemicals derailed in East Palestine, Ohio, resulting in a release of dangerous substances into the environment. This incident led to a class-action lawsuit involving nearly half a million residents. After extensive environmental testing and expert analysis, both sides reached a settlement to avoid prolonged litigation. The settlement established a $600 million fund, allowing residents to receive direct payments and, if desired, additional compensation for waiving personal injury claims. Those with extraordinary losses or injuries could submit claims for further individualized consideration.Prior to this appeal, some objectors challenged the settlement, asserting that class counsel should have reviewed and disclosed more expert evidence regarding long-term risks. The United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, after a fairness hearing, approved the settlement and rejected these objections. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed that approval, citing the adequacy and fairness of the settlement process and the sufficiency of the evidence considered.A small group of residents who had waived personal injury claims subsequently sought relief from the settlement, alleging fraud and misconduct by class counsel and Norfolk Southern. The Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court's denial of relief under Rule 60 for abuse of discretion. The court held that the movants failed to demonstrate fraud on the court, fraud by an opposing party, or extraordinary circumstances warranting relief under Rule 60(b)(3), 60(d)(3), or 60(b)(6). The court further concluded that the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying an evidentiary hearing. The main holding is that the settlement approval stands and the movants are not entitled to relief from judgment. The disposition by the Sixth Circuit is affirmed. View "In re: E. Palestine Train Derailment" on Justia Law