Justia U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Real Estate & Property Law
Sinmier, LLC v. Everest Indemnity Ins. Co.
A commercial real estate lender provided a loan to a hotel operator to purchase a resort in Ohio, secured by a mortgage. The borrower, obligated to secure insurance on the property, worked with an insurance broker to obtain coverage. However, after policy cancellations and changes, the lender’s interest as a mortgagee was not fully protected under the final insurance policy. The borrower defaulted, and the lender sued for breach of contract, fraud, and related claims, ultimately settling by accepting a deed in lieu of foreclosure, which was considered full payment of the borrower’s debt. The settlement also included an additional payment obligation secured by a consent judgment.Following the settlement, the lender brought suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio against the insurance broker, the insurance provider, and an underwriter, seeking damages for not properly securing its mortgagee interest. The claims included breach of contract, negligence, and misrepresentation. The district court granted summary judgment in favor of all defendants, finding that the lender’s mortgagee interest had been extinguished by the settlement and deed in lieu of foreclosure, thereby eliminating any insurable interest required to support its claims.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court’s decision de novo, applying Ohio law. The appellate court held that a mortgagee’s insurable interest is tied to the existence of the underlying debt; once the debt is satisfied or released, the mortgagee’s interest and right to insurance proceeds are extinguished. The court found that the settlement agreement and acceptance of the deed in lieu of foreclosure satisfied the debt and ended the lender’s insurable interest. The appellate court affirmed the district court’s summary judgment for the defendants. View "Sinmier, LLC v. Everest Indemnity Ins. Co." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Insurance Law, Real Estate & Property Law
Summit Locations, LLC v. Bd. of Trustees, Bath Township
A company engaged in outdoor advertising sought to erect a large billboard in a business district of Bath Township, Ohio. The local zoning inspector denied its application, citing a categorical ban on “off-premises” signs under the township’s zoning resolution. The company’s proposed billboard would have been a two-sided structure, 30 feet tall and 360 square feet per side. Notably, the company did not challenge other relevant provisions of the zoning resolution, such as the bans on “pole signs” and “high-rise” signs, which also would have prohibited the proposed billboard.The company, joined by a related entity, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, asserting that the off-premises sign ban violated the First Amendment and conflicted with Ohio law. The defendants, Bath Township’s board of trustees and zoning officials, moved to dismiss on the ground that the plaintiffs lacked standing because even if the off-premises ban were invalidated, other unchallenged provisions would still bar the billboard. The district court agreed and dismissed the case, declining to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the state law claim.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal. The court held that the plaintiffs lacked Article III standing because invalidating the off-premises sign ban would not redress their injury, as the bans on pole and high-rise signs would independently prohibit the billboard. The court found that this reasoning was controlled by its prior decision in Midwest Media Property, L.L.C. v. Symmes Township. The Sixth Circuit also found that the plaintiffs had forfeited any alternative standing theories, such as those based on the permitting process or application fees, by not properly raising them. The judgment of the district court was affirmed. View "Summit Locations, LLC v. Bd. of Trustees, Bath Township" on Justia Law
O’Connor v. Eubanks
Dennis O’Connor had two non-interest-bearing financial accounts with private companies. After O’Connor lost contact with these companies, they transferred his accounts to the State of Michigan under the state’s Uniform Unclaimed Property Act, which governs the handling of unclaimed property. Michigan took custody of O’Connor’s accounts and deposited the funds into its general fund, where the money could generate interest for the state. When O’Connor learned of this, he contended that the state’s failure to pay him the interest earned while holding his money violated his constitutional rights.Previously, the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan dismissed all of O’Connor’s claims, finding that the state took ownership of his accounts and thus owed him no interest. On an earlier appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of his takings claims but vacated the dismissal of his due process claims and remanded for further proceedings. On remand, the district court again dismissed O’Connor’s due process claims, reasoning that Michigan’s ownership of the accounts meant O’Connor had no right to the interest and that the procedures provided were constitutionally sufficient.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the dismissal de novo. The court held that under Michigan law, the state only assumes custody—not ownership—of unclaimed property, and the original owner retains title to both the principal and any interest generated. The court found that the district court erred by following contrary state appellate precedent and by concluding that O’Connor had no property interest in the funds or the interest. The court vacated the district court’s judgment dismissing the due process claims and remanded for further proceedings, directing the lower court to analyze the due process claim based on the correct understanding that O’Connor retained ownership rights. View "O'Connor v. Eubanks" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Real Estate & Property Law
SW Nashville EB Owner, LLC v. Metro. Gov’t of Nashville & Davidson Cnty.
The dispute centers on a property owner that purchased a vacant and dilapidated parcel in Nashville’s East Bank district, intending to redevelop it into a multi-family residential project in accordance with local zoning rules. The owner submitted a building permit application that, according to its allegations, fully complied with all applicable zoning requirements. However, in mid-2022, the local government placed an indefinite “development hold” on the property, effectively barring any consideration or approval of the permit. The stated reason was that authorities were assessing possible routes for a planned major roadway that might require acquisition of part of the property. As a result, the owner claims the property has become undevelopable and unsellable, resulting in millions of dollars in carrying costs.After unsuccessful efforts to have the hold lifted, the owner filed suit in state court, alleging violations of the Takings and Due Process Clauses of the U.S. Constitution and the Tennessee Constitution. The case was removed to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, where the defendants moved to dismiss on several grounds, including untimeliness and qualified immunity. The district court, on its own initiative, dismissed the complaint for lack of “jurisdictional” ripeness, reasoning that there had been no final decision on the permit application.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit considered only the ripeness issue. The court held that the owner’s claims were both constitutionally and prudentially ripe because the local government’s development hold constituted a definitive, final decision barring any development of the property. The appellate court reversed the district court’s dismissal and remanded the case for further proceedings on the remaining issues. View "SW Nashville EB Owner, LLC v. Metro. Gov't of Nashville & Davidson Cnty." on Justia Law
Sullivan v. Miller
Jason Wylie, a farmer and business owner, experienced significant financial distress following a serious illness in 2018 that left him unable to manage his farm and businesses. Over the preceding years, Wylie and his mother, Kathleen Sullivan, engaged in several financial transactions, including property transfers and loans. In August 2019, Wylie transferred three pieces of real property back to Sullivan by quitclaim deed, with two properties still subject to mortgages. The parties executed a “Mutual Release in Full” to settle the debt. In August 2020, Wylie filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, seeking to discharge nearly $2 million in debt. The bankruptcy trustee filed an adversary proceeding against Sullivan to avoid one of the property transfers, alleging it was constructively fraudulent and intended to shield assets from creditors.The United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Michigan found that Wylie received less than reasonably equivalent value in exchange for the property transferred to Sullivan, determining the transfer was constructively fraudulent under 11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B)(i). The court ordered Sullivan to return one of the properties to the estate. Sullivan appealed to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, which affirmed the bankruptcy court’s decision.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the bankruptcy court’s legal conclusions de novo and factual findings for clear error, with no deference to the district court’s decision. The Sixth Circuit held that Wylie did not personally guarantee the business loan to Sullivan, the Mutual Release did not cover damages from a prior conversion of funds, and the bankruptcy court did not abuse its discretion by ordering recovery of the transferred property rather than its value. The court affirmed the district court’s judgment. View "Sullivan v. Miller" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Bankruptcy, Real Estate & Property Law
Sinclair v. Meisner
Several homeowners lost their properties through foreclosure after failing to pay property taxes to Oakland County, Michigan. Although the properties’ values exceeded the tax debts, the County retained all surplus equity rather than refunding the difference to the owners. The affected individuals, represented by attorney Scott Smith and later the McAlpine PC firm, brought suit alleging that this retention violated the Takings Clause of the U.S. Constitution.Both cases were initially dismissed by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan for failure to state a claim. The plaintiffs appealed. In the Hall case, the Pacific Legal Foundation represented the plaintiffs pro bono. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed, holding that the County’s actions constituted a violation of the Takings Clause. The district court subsequently denied motions for class certification and the parties settled for $500,000. Plaintiffs then sought attorney fees totaling over $4.2 million, including hours spent on failed class certification and appeals largely handled by other counsel. The district court reduced the fee request by 40% and applied a 1.1 multiplier, awarding $1,361,476.51.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the fee award for abuse of discretion and determined that the district court erred in several respects. The appellate court held that hours spent on failed class certification, litigation against other defendants, and certain other tasks were not properly billable and should have been categorically excluded. The court also found that the hours claimed for appellate work and by Mark McAlpine were grossly excessive, and that the district court failed to address the reasonableness of the hourly rates. The Sixth Circuit vacated the fee award and remanded, instructing the district court to recalculate fees with specific exclusions, a blended $325 hourly rate, and a 1.1 multiplier. No fees were awarded for the present appeal. View "Sinclair v. Meisner" on Justia Law
Rubicon Real Estate Holdings v. City of Pontiac
A Michigan-based real estate developer and related parties sought to redevelop a commercial property in the City of Pontiac to include medical marijuana cultivation and processing facilities. After purchasing the property in 2019, the developer obtained rezoning approval from the city, but the process of securing required permits and special exceptions for tenants became protracted. The city clerk cited deficiencies in tenant applications and, at one point, argued that the project violated city ordinances regarding overlay districts for marijuana businesses. Despite eventual approvals—including a court order requiring the city to issue permits—the tenants withdrew due to the delays, and the project collapsed. Subsequently, the developer’s affiliate lost another business opportunity, which plaintiffs attributed to city officials’ retaliation.The plaintiffs filed suit in Oakland County Circuit Court, seeking injunctive, declaratory, and monetary relief, and later brought civil rights claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. The district court granted summary judgment for the city and the city clerk, finding insufficient evidence of constitutional violations and concluding that the delays and alleged retaliation did not violate the plaintiffs’ rights.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The court held that the plaintiffs lacked a cognizable property interest under the Due Process Clause because city approval for marijuana facilities was discretionary, not a matter of right. The court also found that the delays did not constitute a “taking” under the Fifth Amendment, as the length and nature of the delays were not extraordinary. The equal protection claim failed for lack of evidence that similarly situated applicants were treated more favorably. Finally, the court determined that the plaintiffs’ First Amendment retaliation claim could not proceed against the city because the mayor lacked final policymaking authority over zoning and no municipal policy or custom was established. View "Rubicon Real Estate Holdings v. City of Pontiac" on Justia Law
Reinhardt v. Prince
A property owner in Bay County, Michigan, failed to pay property taxes in 2019, resulting in the county initiating a foreclosure process under Michigan’s General Property Tax Act (GPTA). After a three-year timeline, a Michigan circuit court entered a foreclosure judgment in February 2022, which would vest absolute title in the county treasurer if the tax debt was not paid by March 31, 2022. The owner did not pay, and the county received title. Shortly after, the owner filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy and sought to avoid the transfer of title as a preferential transfer under the Bankruptcy Code. The county treasurer withdrew the property from auction due to the bankruptcy filing. The parties stipulated to key facts, including the amount of debt, estimated property value, and minimum bid, but disputed whether the transfer met the requirements for avoidance under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b).The United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Michigan granted summary judgment to the county treasurer, finding that although the transfer occurred within the 90-day lookback period, the owner failed to satisfy the "more than" test under § 547(b)(5). The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan affirmed, agreeing that the owner could not show the transfer enabled the treasurer to receive more than he would in a hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation.Upon appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the legal conclusions de novo and factual findings for clear error. The Sixth Circuit held that the transfer occurred within the 90-day lookback period, and that the owner established the transfer was preferential under § 547(b)(4) and § 547(b)(5), specifically because the treasurer would receive a 5% sales commission not available in Chapter 7 liquidation. The district court’s judgment was reversed. View "Reinhardt v. Prince" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Bankruptcy, Real Estate & Property Law
Norton Outdoor Advertising, Inc. v. Village of St. Bernard
A company sought to erect a digital billboard in a small Ohio municipality but was prevented from doing so by the local billboard ordinance, which included restrictions on size, location, and type of billboards permitted. The ordinance specifically banned “variable message” (digital) signs and implemented a “cap and replace” rule, allowing new billboards only if older ones were removed. The ordinance also contained several exemptions, including one for “public service” signs, which were allowed to display information like time or weather if not used for advertising.Previously, the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio granted summary judgment to the municipality, upholding the ordinance against the company’s First Amendment challenges. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit determined that the exemption for public service signs was an unconstitutional, content-based restriction under the First Amendment, but remanded the case for the district court to determine whether the invalid exemption was severable from the rest of the ordinance.On remand, the district court found that the unconstitutional provision could be severed and that the remainder of the ordinance survived intermediate scrutiny, granting judgment again in favor of the municipality. The company appealed.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The appellate court held that the public-service exemption was severable under Ohio law, applying the three-part test from Geiger v. Geiger. The court further held that the remaining provisions of the ordinance were content-neutral and survived intermediate scrutiny because they were narrowly tailored to significant governmental interests such as traffic safety and aesthetics. The court also held that the company was not entitled to damages or attorney fees, as it was not a prevailing party under 42 U.S.C. § 1988(b). View "Norton Outdoor Advertising, Inc. v. Village of St. Bernard" on Justia Law
Lifestyle Communities, Ltd. v. City of Worthington
A real estate developer purchased a vacant parcel of land in Worthington, Ohio, previously owned by a youth home. The property was primarily zoned for public or institutional uses such as parks, hospitals, and churches. The developer sought to build a mixed-use project and applied for rezoning and development plan approval. After public meetings where concerns about greenspace, traffic, and density were raised, the municipal planning commission tabled the initial application. The developer later reduced the number of proposed residential units, but the commission still declined to recommend approval, and the city council denied the rezoning application. Subsequently, the city amended its comprehensive plan to emphasize greenspace. The developer, having purchased the property after waiving a rezoning contingency, filed suit, alleging constitutional violations due to the city’s refusal to rezone and amend the comprehensive plan.The United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio dismissed most of the developer’s claims at the motion-to-dismiss stage, including due process counts, and granted summary judgment to the city on the remaining regulatory takings and declaratory judgment claims. The developer appealed, challenging the dismissal and grant of summary judgment.The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the grant of summary judgment and dismissal de novo. The court held that the city’s actions did not constitute a regulatory taking under the Penn Central factors, as the developer lacked a reasonable investment-backed expectation of rezoning approval and the city’s actions had legitimate public purposes. The court also found that the zoning ordinance was not unconstitutional beyond fair debate and that the developer failed to allege a cognizable property interest or arbitrary government action for its due process claims. The Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment in all respects. View "Lifestyle Communities, Ltd. v. City of Worthington" on Justia Law